Should You Break Your Mortgage Early? A Canadian Break-Even Guide
A lower mortgage rate may save interest, but the penalty and closing costs can outweigh the benefit. Compare the full cost of changing now with keeping your current mortgage until the end of its term.
Start with a dated payout quote and a written replacement offer. Use the same borrowing amount, remaining repayment period and comparison date for both options.
A smaller payment can help your monthly budget. It does not, by itself, show that the new mortgage costs less.
In this guide
Start with a dated payout quote
An open mortgage can be ended without a prepayment penalty. Breaking a closed mortgage normally involves one. Other costs may include administration, appraisal, reinvestment or discharge fees, plus repayment of a cash-back incentive. The FCAC guide to breaking a mortgage contract explains these potential charges.
Prepayment calculations vary. The FCAC prepayment penalty guide describes common calculations, including three months’ interest and the interest rate differential, or IRD. An IRD can depend on posted or discounted rates and the term remaining. Your agreement determines the actual calculation.
Ask for the amount on your intended closing date, how it was calculated and how long the quote remains valid. An online estimate or an old quote may not be the amount payable when you leave.
Keep professional and registry costs separate from the lender’s discharge fee. FCAC notes that discharge procedures and charges vary by province or territory.
Compare two repayment schedules to the same date
Start with the months left in your current term. If one year remains, compare both mortgages over that year first. Then consider the longer commitment created by the replacement term. Rates available after the old term ends are unknown.
Stay
Record total mortgage payments, interest charged and the remaining balance at the current term-end date.
Change now
Record the same figures to that date, plus the penalty and closing costs. Show any costs added to the new loan separately.
Compare
For equal starting balances and cash-paid costs, subtract the new schedule’s interest and net switching costs from the old schedule’s interest. A positive difference is a cost advantage under those assumptions.
As a cross-check, add the payments made and the mortgage balance remaining at the comparison date for each option. Add any cash-paid switching costs to the replacement option. Do not also add the interest difference; that would count part of the benefit twice.
Dividing costs by the monthly payment reduction measures a simple cash-recovery period. It does not measure the full borrowing-cost break-even point because payments include both principal and interest.
A worked example: payment relief versus borrowing cost
Illustration only. These are hypothetical rates and costs, rather than a lending offer, penalty quote or approval estimate. Assume a $400,000 balance, 20 years remaining, 18 months left in the current term, monthly payments and two fixed rates: 5.50% if you stay and 4.25% if you change. Assume $6,000 in total switching costs, paid in cash, with no added borrowing.
Stay at 5.50%
Monthly payment: about $2,737.57.
Interest over 18 months: about $31,971.
Balance after 18 months: about $382,695.
Change to 4.25%
Monthly payment: about $2,469.02.
Interest over 18 months: about $24,694.
Balance after 18 months: about $380,252.
The modelled interest difference is about $7,277. After the $6,000 cash cost, the change has an approximate $1,277 cost advantage over these 18 months. Cumulative interest savings first exceed $6,000 at the fifteenth monthly payment.
The payment reduction is about $268.55 per month, or $4,834 over 18 months. That alone does not recover the $6,000 cash outlay by term end. The new schedule also leaves the borrower owing about $2,443 less, which explains the difference between cash relief and the cost comparison.
A replacement term that continues beyond month 18 creates a longer commitment. This example does not predict the rate available when the old mortgage would renew, or account for a future exit penalty on the replacement loan.
Keep changes in borrowing and repayment visible
A longer amortization can lower the payment while increasing the time you pay interest. FCAC cautions against treating an extension as a cost saving without reviewing total interest.
If you add penalties or fees to the mortgage, start the new schedule with that higher balance. Do not use the cash-paid example above unchanged. Financing the costs can also affect qualification and creates interest on the added debt.
If you replace a fixed mortgage with a variable one, calculate several possible rate paths. FCAC explains that variable interest can rise or fall, with the effect on payments and principal depending on the product.
Resolve approval before relying on the replacement rate. Refinancing at a bank requires qualification, including stress testing. An exception for an eligible switch at renewal should not be assumed to cover an early exit. Confirm approval conditions before arranging to repay your current loan.
Compare the alternatives to breaking your mortgage
Some lenders offer blend-and-extend: an early renewal combining your existing rate with a new term’s rate. FCAC describes this option as avoiding a prepayment penalty, although administration fees may apply. Get the blended rate, fees and new term length in writing before comparing it with a switch.
If you are moving, ask whether the existing mortgage can be ported to the next property and what restrictions apply. A smaller replacement mortgage or additional borrowing can change the outcome.
If you have cash available, ask about permitted lump-sum or increased payments. FCAC notes that privileges have limits and timing rules. Check those terms before using a prepayment as part of an exit plan.
Compare these options on the same date and borrowing assumptions. Waiting avoids a decision today, but the rate available at renewal remains unknown. A forecast should not be entered as a confirmed offer.
Prepare the figures before committing to a switch
Bring your agreement, recent statement and the lender’s payout quote. Ask for a comparison that records:
- The closing date and months remaining in the current term.
- The penalty, cash-back repayment and every other exit charge.
- New closing costs and any written lender contribution.
- The starting balance, payment and remaining amortization for both routes.
- Total interest and the balance at the common comparison date.
- Approval conditions, rate-hold expiry and the new mortgage’s exit terms.
Record why you want to change. Lower monthly payments, a move, additional borrowing and lower interest costs are different goals and may lead to different comparisons.
Powerhaus’s mortgage renewal options provide the next step for reviewing the figures. Ask for the cost of changing now alongside the cost of keeping your current mortgage.
Questions homeowners ask before breaking a mortgage
Is a lower monthly payment enough to make breaking worthwhile?
No. Check interest, closing costs and the balance remaining on the same date. Extending amortization can lower payments while increasing interest costs. Payment relief alone does not establish a saving.
Will a fixed mortgage penalty always be three months’ interest?
No. The lender may use an IRD calculation, and its method matters. Obtain the actual dated quote and compare it with the calculation in your agreement.
Can I add the penalty to my new mortgage?
Ask whether the lender permits and approves it. Include the added debt and interest in the comparison, and confirm qualification. Cash-paid and financed costs produce different repayment schedules.
Does using a prepayment privilege before leaving reduce the penalty?
A permitted prepayment can reduce the balance used in a future calculation. FCAC warns that some lenders restrict prepayments near an exit date. Confirm the timing and quote before transferring the funds.
Can the penalty change while I am arranging the new loan?
Yes. Ask what can change the amount, how long the quote is valid and when it must be updated. The FCAC prepayment rights guide covers these details for lenders following the code of conduct.
Find out what the lower rate would actually save
Bring your current mortgage details, payout quote and replacement offer to Powerhaus. Compare leaving now, waiting until renewal and any available early-renewal option before committing.